2026 NFL Draft Futures: Number 4 Overall Pick Betting Odds & Prediction

The first few picks of the NFL Draft are always the most intriguing, and so it will be with the 2026 edition in Pittsburgh this week from April 23-25. We know the Las Vegas Raiders are taking Indiana Heisman Trophy-winning QB Fernando Mendoza with the No. 1 overall pick, so it’s the selections following that one which are of the most interest.

The Jets are likely to take one of the top two pass-rushers in David Bailey or Arvel Reese at No. 2 overall. At No. 3, the Cardinals seem poised to take whichever of those two players the Jets don’t take or standout back Jeremiyah Love. At No. 4 overall, the Tennessee Titans are up.

They picked first last year and tied for the worst record in the NFL in 2025, going 3-14. That’s led Tennessee brass to look at this No. 4 pick as a situation where they can’t really go wrong. They’ve got so many holes to fill, and there will no doubt be a bevy of options when they get on the clock. So who will they roll with? Read on for the favorites and NFL betting odds as well as our own analysis and prediction for this futures betting market!

2026 NFL Draft Futures: Who Will Be the No. 4 Overall Pick? - NFL Betting Odds & Picks

All betting odds provided by Betway.

Player, Position (School)	No. 4 Overall Pick Odds
Jeremiyah Love, RB (Notre Dame)	-115
David Bailey, DE (Texas Tech)	+400
Sonny Styles, LB (Ohio State)	+450
Arvell Reese, LB (Ohio State)	+700
Carnell Tate, WR (Ohio State)	+1,000
Rueben Bain Jr., DE (Miami)	+1,800
Francis Mauigoa, OT (Miami)	+2,800
Jordyn Tyson, WR (Arizona State)	+2,800
Caleb Downs, S (Ohio State)	+4,000
Mansoor Delane, CB (LSU)	+6,000
Monroe Freeling, OT (Georgia)	+7,000
Spencer Fano, OT (Utah)	+7,000

The Favorite: Jeremiyah Love, RB, Notre Dame (-115)

Apart from Mendoza at No. 1, there aren’t too many of these specific draft pick futures markets where the favorite has minus odds. But Jeremiyah Love does at -115 here. The Titans do have Tony Pollard, who just had a 1,000-yard season, but will they let an average starter like that keep them from a generational talent like Love? Maybe. But anyways, we think there’s a great chance Love goes at No. 3 overall, so he won’t even be here with the Titans come up. And even if he was, we think there’s a better fit.

The Best of the Rest: Sonny Styles, LB, Ohio State (+450)

While his Buckeye linebacker buddy Arvell Reese is the much more highly-touted prospect, Sonny Styles is probably the better football player right now. He’s what we now like to call a “green dot guy”, meaning he's a versatile middle linebacker that can take on the responsibility of relaying the defensive coordinator’s instructions on the field, calling plays, and pointing out audibles. And he can also stop the run and cover the pass and all that athletic stuff too, obviously.

Styles is exactly the type of player a defensive guru like Robert Saleh wants to build his unit around. We’re not saying he’s going to turn into Fred Warner.. but think Fred Warner when Saleh was the DC in San Francisco. Some insiders have said that Tennessee believes Styles is the safer pick over Love, and that does make sense.

Titans GM Mike Borgonzi recently mentioned the middle linebacker when answering a question about the team’s top pick. And with all of the holes, we’re not sure the Titans really have the luxury to draft Love when they already have Pollard. Not to mention Borgonzi’s history in this job and in the K.C. Chiefs’ front office suggests he does not value RBs highly in the draft. Let’s go with the value on this one.