Cavaliers vs. Pacers NBA Playoffs Series Futures Betting Markets

Alex Murray
By: Alex Murray
04 May 25
NBA Picks
Photo by Wikimedia Commons, CC by 2.0

Photo by Wikimedia Commons, CC by 2.0

The first series in the second round of these 2025 NBA Playoffs gets underway on Sunday evening. Before the paint has even dried on the first round in the West, we get Game 1 of the No. 1 Cleveland Cavaliers’ Eastern Conference semifinals matchup against the No. 4 Indiana Pacers.

There is a bevy of fun and intriguing futures betting markets for this series, such as “series correct” score”, “player to score most points in the series”, and more! Check out all the options below and who we think is offering the most value according to the betting odds.

Highlights

  • Indiana’s ability to score and sheer depth tells us they will win 2 games at least
  • The value on Cleveland winning this series in six games is excellent right now
  • Jarrett Allen is averaging nearly 4 more rebounds per game than anyone in this series

Cleveland Cavaliers vs. Indiana Pacers NBA Playoffs Round 2 Futures Betting Markets - May 4

All odds provided by Sports Interaction.

Cavaliers vs. Pacers “Series Result” Futures Betting Markets

TeamTo Win SeriesSeries SpreadSeries Total Games
Cleveland Cavaliers-500-2.5 (-105)Over 5.5 (-120)
Indiana Pacers+375+2.5 (-135)Under 5.5 (-120)

The Cavaliers have been arguably the most dominant and consistent team in the league this year. They just wallopped the Miami Heat 4-0 in the first round, winning those games by an average of 30.5 points. There’s just no scenario short of a major injury where we can see them falling short of the Eastern Conference Finals.

However, the Pacers are an intriguing foe. Their pulse-pounding offense is a good matchup for Cleveland’s elite defense, and they are as deep as they are talented. Indiana was actually 3-1 against Cleveland during the regular season, so we like them to push this at least to a Game 6.

Best Bet: Indiana Pacers +2.5 Series Spread (-135)

Cavaliers vs. Pacers “Series Correct Score” Futures Betting Market

ScoreCleveland Cavaliers to WinIndiana Pacers to Win
4-0+350+4,000
4-1+230+2,200
4-2+400+1,000
4-3+425+1,000

This one kind of ties in with our first pick, but is just a little more specific. For these futures bets, the betting apps are offering odds on how many games it would take either team to win. For that reason, all eight options are offering pretty good value with plus odds.

The Pacers were 29-11 at home this year, second-best in the East behind only the Cavaliers, so we expect them to get one win at home early and maybe surprise the Cavs in another. At +400, the Cavs to win 4-2 makes a lot of sense. A sweep would shock us, and seven games is pushing it even for Indiana truthers. So it’s really between 4-1 and 4-2. And with 4-1 offering about half the value at +230, the decision was easy.

Best Bet: Cleveland Cavaliers to Win 4-2 (+400)

Cavaliers vs. Pacers “Most X In Series” Futures Betting Market

PlayerMost PointsMost ReboundsMost BlocksMost Steals
Donovan Mitchell (CLE)-450+8,000+20,000+450
Pascal Siakam (IND)+850+2,200+4,500+1,200
Darius Garland (IND)+1,200+1,000N/AN/A
Tyrese Haliburton (IND)+1,200+5,000+475+200
Evan Mobley (CLE)+3,000+150+275+2,500
Myles Turner (IND)+5,000+3,300-160+8,000
Ty Jerome (CLE)+8,000+9,000N/A+1,200
Andrew Nembhard (IND)+10,000+8,000+12,500+350
Aaron Nesmith (IND)+12,500+6,000+4,500+3,300
T.J. McConnell (IND)+15,000+10,000N/A+3,000
Jarrett Allen (CLE)+15,000-170+1,200+325

The scoring prop here seems locked in for Donovan Mitchell and not worth touching. However, the favorites in the rebounding and blocks categories seem like locks. Myles Turner, at -160, had more than twice as many blocks (11) in the first round as anyone else in this series. Meanwhile, Jarrett Allen (-170) averaged over 10 rebounds per game in the first round while no one else in this series averaged more than 6.5.

Another one we like is Donovan Mitchell for most steals at tasty +450 odds. He had six in the first round, more than all but Allen, who had 10. However, six of Allen’s came in one game, and the only guy to average more steals than Mitchell in the regular season was Tyrese Haliburton. The Pacers guard is the favorite and so is offering considerably less value at +200.

Best Bet:

  • Jarrett Allen Most Rebounds in Series (-170)
  • Donovan Mitchell Most Steals in Series (+450)
  • Myles Turner Most Blocks in Series (-160)/Sports Interaction
Sports Intercation
125% Up To C$250

Alex is a recent graduate of Ryerson's Sport Media program in 2019 and has been contributing to BettingTop10 since 2020. He has worked in the field of sports and sports betting for several years, including writing for theScore and daily fantasy sports website FantasyPros as one of their lead NBA news writers. A dedicated sports fan and experienced sports bettor, Alex has the knowledge to provide you with the best betting advice and the sneakiest props no matter what the sport may be.